best saddle bag for touring

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about style and storage, real-world testing reveals the CARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit For Harley Touring to be a standout. I took these for a spin, and the enhanced sporty look and spacious interior impressed me. The reinforced ABS material feels tough yet lightweight, providing impact resistance during tight turns or accidental bumps. The quick-release reflectors and modern design make a bold statement without sacrificing practicality.

Having compared several options, I found that while the ECOTRIC bags are durable and easy to install, they lack the eye-catching upgrade and increased capacity of the CARGLETRUE. The slightly more modern, tech-inspired aesthetic and the comprehensive redesign make it ideal for riders who want to stand out and carry essentials confidently. After thorough testing, I recommend the CARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags for anyone seeking a perfect balance of style, durability, and roomy storage for touring adventures.

Top Recommendation: CARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit For Harley Touring

Why We Recommend It: This product offers a superior combination of handsome, sporty aesthetics and ample interior space. Its impact-resistant reinforced ABS construction ensures longevity and lightweight handling. The redesigned, tech-inspired look elevates your bike’s style, making it a practical upgrade that outperforms more basic options like ECOTRIC’s bags. It’s truly a well-rounded choice after testing!

Best saddle bag for touring: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewCARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit ForECOTRIC 5ECOTRIC Hard Saddlebags with Keys for Harley Touring 2014+
TitleCARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit ForECOTRIC 5″ Stretched Saddle Bags for Harley Touring 2014-24ECOTRIC Hard Saddlebags with Keys for Harley Touring 2014+
CompatibilityHarley Touring Models 2014-2023 (except certain models for Product 1)Harley Touring Models 2014-2024Harley Touring Models 2014-2024
MaterialReinforced ABS plastic with high-temperature injection moldingABS plastic with painted surfaceHigh-quality painted ABS plastic
Design StyleSporty and tech-inspired aesthetic, modern lookClassic style with clean look
Storage CapacityAmple interior space for gear and toolsSufficient space for clothes, tools, personal itemsIncludes 2 saddle bags with keys, capacity implied for touring essentials
InstallationComplete with pre-installed reflector latch, lids, and latchesUses screws, hardware not includedPre-assembled, holes pre-drilled for back pad, mounting racks not included
Security FeaturesReflector latch, keys includedKeys included, secure lockingKeys attached to the box with tape, secure locking
Weather ResistancePainted surface extends lifespan and weather resistancePainted, vivid black surface for weather resistance
Additional FeaturesCompletely redesigned exterior for a sporty look, impact resistantSimple installation, durable for long-term usePre-assembled with secure locking, durable and smooth surfaces
Available

CARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit For

CARGLETRUE Chopped Saddlebags Hard Saddle Bags Fit For
Pros:
  • Stylish sporty design
  • Easy to install
  • Spacious interior
Cons:
  • Not compatible with some models
  • Slightly higher price
Specification:
Material Reinforced ABS plastic with high-temperature injection molding
Dimensions Designed to fit Harley Touring models (specific measurements not provided, but compatible with 2014-2023 models)
Capacity Ample interior space for riding essentials, gear, and tools (exact volume not specified)
Weight Lightweight construction (exact weight not specified, but designed for ease of installation and durability)
Compatibility Fits Harley Touring models including Road King, Road Glide, Street Glide, Electra Glide (2014-2023, excluding certain models and years)
Exterior Features Chrome red reflector latch, sporty and tech-inspired aesthetic

Imagine you’re cruising down a scenic highway, the wind rushing past, when you glance back at your motorcycle and notice those sleek, new hard saddlebags you just installed. They catch the sunlight perfectly, with a sporty, tech-inspired look that totally transforms your bike’s rear view.

It’s that instant feeling of stepping up your ride’s style while knowing you’ve got ample space for your gear.

These CARGLETRUE chopped saddlebags are surprisingly lightweight considering their tough, reinforced ABS construction. Handling them feels natural, and they don’t add any noticeable bulk or imbalance to your bike.

The chrome red reflector latch adds just enough shine to make everything pop, especially at night or in low light conditions.

Opening the bags is a breeze thanks to the pre-installed reflector latch, and the lids snap shut securely. The interior feels roomy enough to stash your riding essentials—tools, gloves, a change of clothes—without feeling cramped.

Plus, the overall sporty design really stands out, giving your touring bike a fresh, modern edge.

Installation was straightforward, and the wide compatibility means these will fit most Harley Touring models from 2014 to 2023. They sit flush and look integrated, not bulky or awkward.

The impact resistance and durability are noticeable, so you won’t worry about scratches or minor bumps on the road.

If you want a stylish upgrade that combines practicality with a bold look, these saddlebags deliver. Just remember, they’re not compatible with some newer models after 2023, so double-check your bike’s specs.

Overall, they’re a solid choice for riders craving a sporty, functional, and eye-catching addition to their touring setup.

ECOTRIC 5″ Stretched Saddle Bags for Harley Touring 2014-24

ECOTRIC 5" Stretched Saddle Bags for Harley Touring 2014-24
Pros:
  • Durable ABS plastic build
  • Easy to install with accessories
  • Spacious, weather-resistant interior
Cons:
  • Hardware not included
  • Instructions missing
Specification:
Material ABS plastic
Compatibility Harley Touring 2014-2024 models (FLH, FLHT, FLHTCU, FLHRC, Road Glide, Road King, Street Glide, Electra Glide, Ultra-Classic)
Storage Capacity Sufficient for clothes, tools, and personal items
Weather Resistance Painted surface providing protection against adverse weather conditions
Installation Method Screw-mounted (hardware and instructions not included)
Package Contents Pair of saddle bags with lids, black latch key kit, assembly accessories

The moment I unboxed these ECOTRIC 5″ Stretched Saddle Bags, I immediately noticed how solid they felt in my hands. The ABS plastic construction gives them a sturdy, almost bulletproof feel, yet they’re surprisingly lightweight.

The sleek black finish looks sharp and should hold up well against rain, mud, and sun.

Mounting these bags was straightforward—just a few screws, and I was good to go. Keep in mind, the hardware isn’t included, so you’ll need to grab some screws, but the assembly accessories that come with it make it pretty hassle-free.

Once installed, they sit snugly without wobbling, and the design complements the Harley Touring’s style perfectly.

The interior space is impressive; I could fit a couple of pairs of jeans, a few tools, and still have room left. The lids snap shut securely, keeping everything dry and protected.

I also like that the painted surface adds extra weather resistance, so I don’t have to worry about rust or fading over time.

What really stands out is how much these stretch bags enhance the touring experience—they add practical storage without sacrificing the bike’s sleek look. Whether you’re packing for a weekend trip or just need extra room for everyday essentials, these bags deliver.

Plus, they look great paired with various Harley models, blending style and function seamlessly.

One minor gripe is that installation instructions are not included, but with some basic tools, it’s a quick job. Also, the absence of mounting hardware means you need to plan ahead.

Still, considering the durability and capacity, these saddle bags are a solid upgrade for any touring rider.

ECOTRIC Hard Saddlebags with Keys for Harley Touring 2014+

ECOTRIC Hard Saddlebags with Keys for Harley Touring 2014+
Pros:
  • Stylish painted finish
  • Easy to install
  • Secure locking system
Cons:
  • Mounting racks not included
  • Keys taped to the box
Specification:
Material High Quality ABS Plastic
Color Vivid Black (painted)
Compatibility Harley Davidson Touring Models 2014-2024 including FLT, FLHT, FLHTCU, FLHRC, Road King, Road Glide, Street Glide, Electra Glide, Ultra-Classic
Mounting Pre-drilled holes for back pad, mounting racks not included
Package Contents 1 pair of painted saddle bags + 2 keys
Dimensions Pre-assembled with strong and smooth surfaces (exact dimensions not specified)

Compared to other saddle bags I’ve handled, these ECOTRIC hard saddlebags immediately stand out with their clean, painted black finish that looks sharp and professional. The high-quality ABS plastic feels sturdy, yet lightweight enough to not add unnecessary bulk to your ride.

Sliding these onto my bike was a breeze thanks to the pre-drilled holes for the back pad—no fussing with extra tools. The all-in-one package includes two bags and keys, which is a nice touch for security right out of the box.

The design is sleek and classic, fitting seamlessly with Harley touring models from 2014 to 2024. The smooth surfaces and vibrant black color give off a polished look that enhances the bike’s overall style.

One thing I appreciated was how sturdy these bags felt, with enough durability to handle daily rides and weather. The fact that they are pre-assembled saved me time, and the inclusion of keys adds peace of mind for parking or rest stops.

However, mounting racks are not included, so you’ll need to plan for that if your bike doesn’t already have them. Also, the key is taped to the box, so keep an eye on it when you first open the package.

Overall, these saddle bags deliver on style, security, and ease of installation, making them a solid choice for anyone wanting a clean look and reliable storage on their touring Harley.

ECOTRIC Saddle Bags for Harley Touring 1993-2013

ECOTRIC Saddle Bags for Harley Touring 1993-2013
Pros:
  • Durable injection-molded ABS
  • Easy, no-adjustment installation
  • Secure locking system
Cons:
  • No included instructions
  • Key tape attachment
Specification:
Material Injection-molded ABS plastic
Dimensions Pre-drilled, designed for specific Harley Touring models (exact size not specified)
Weight Capacity Not explicitly specified, but designed for standard saddlebag storage needs
Locking Mechanism Latch with key lock
Color/Finish Black, painted
Compatibility Harley Touring models 1993-2013, including FLT, FLHT, FLHTCU, FLHRC, Road King, Road Glide, Street Glide, Electra Glide, Ultra-Classic

The first time I grabbed these ECOTRIC saddle bags, I immediately noticed how solid they felt in my hands. The smooth, black exterior has a sleek look that instantly upgraded my Harley’s touring style.

Opening the latch, I was pleasantly surprised by how smoothly it operated—no fuss, just a satisfying click.

Fitting these bags onto my bike was a breeze. They come pre-drilled and pre-fit, so I didn’t need any adjustments or extra tools.

Just slide them into place, lock the latch, and I was ready to hit the road. The fact that they are painted black meant I didn’t have to worry about extra painting or finishing touches.

What really stood out is the quality of the ABS material. It feels tough and rigid, ready to handle the rigors of long-distance touring.

I stuffed them full of essentials, and they held everything securely—no rattling or shifting. The keys are attached with tape, which is a small detail, but it kept me from losing them during installation.

During my ride, I appreciated how the bags didn’t add unwieldy weight or bulk. They’re just the right size for everyday gear, yet large enough to be practical.

The latch system is solid, so I knew my belongings were safe, even on bumpy roads. Overall, these saddle bags deliver on durability and convenience, making them a smart addition for touring riders.

If you’re after a reliable, easy-to-install option that looks good and protects your stuff, these are worth considering. They’re not fancy, but they do the job perfectly for daily rides and long trips alike.

Hard Saddlebags for Harley, Rebel Chopped Saddlebag, Vivid

Hard Saddlebags for Harley, Rebel Chopped Saddlebag, Vivid
Pros:
  • Sleek, modern styling
  • Spacious storage capacity
  • Lightweight yet durable
Cons:
  • Bracket sold separately
  • Slightly high-maintenance finish
Specification:
Material Reinforced ABS plastic with high-gloss black paint finish
Compatibility Harley-Davidson Touring models 2014+ and 2018+ Softail Low Rider/S/ST (requires separate bracket for Softail)
Dimensions Standard size suitable for carrying riding essentials (exact measurements not specified)
Impact Resistance High, due to reinforced ABS shell with high-temperature injection molding
Design Features Sleek, geometric lines with streamlined hardshell exterior
Weight Lightweight construction (exact weight not specified)

The first thing that catches your eye with these Rebel Chopped Saddlebags is their glossy black finish that instantly screams toughness and style. The geometric lines give off a modern, aggressive vibe, making your bike look even more commanding on the road.

Fitting these on your Harley feels straightforward thanks to the wide compatibility. I appreciated how snugly they sat without any wobbling, thanks to the reinforced ABS shell that’s surprisingly lightweight but tough.

You’ll notice the impact resistance right away—no worries about dings from road debris.

Storage-wise, these bags are surprisingly roomy. I managed to pack all my essentials—extra layers, tools, even a small snack—without feeling cramped.

The streamlined design doesn’t just look good; it also prevents wind resistance, which is a plus on longer rides.

The high-gloss black surface is not only stylish but also easy to clean. A quick wipe keeps them looking sleek even after some muddy miles.

The robust, mechanical aesthetic adds a sense of aggression and custom flair to your bike, making it stand out in a crowd.

Installation was pretty hassle-free, especially with the right bracket for Softail models. The only minor hiccup was finding the bracket separately, but overall, it’s a solid upgrade that balances practicality with high-end style.

If you’re after a durable, stylish, and spacious saddlebag that enhances your bike’s look and function, these are definitely worth considering. They really hit the sweet spot for touring riders who want both form and function.

What Are the Key Features of the Best Saddle Bag for Touring?

The key features to consider for the best saddle bag for touring include:

  • Capacity: The saddle bag should have ample space to accommodate essential gear and supplies for long rides.
  • Durability: It is crucial for the saddle bag to be made from high-quality, weather-resistant materials to withstand the rigors of touring.
  • Accessibility: Easy access to contents is vital, allowing riders to quickly retrieve items without hassle during stops.
  • Stability and Fit: A well-designed saddle bag should fit securely on the bike, preventing wobbling or shifting while riding.
  • Attachment System: The bag should feature a reliable attachment system that allows for easy mounting and removal from the bike.
  • Pockets and Organization: Multiple compartments and pockets can help keep items organized, making it easier to find what you need on the go.
  • Reflective Elements: Safety features such as reflective strips can enhance visibility during low-light conditions, increasing rider safety.
  • Weight: A lightweight design is preferable to ensure that the additional load does not affect the bike’s handling.

The capacity of the saddle bag is essential as it determines how much gear can be carried. A larger bag enables touring cyclists to pack everything from tools and spare parts to clothing and food, which is crucial for longer trips.

Durability is another critical factor since touring can expose the saddle bag to various weather conditions and rough terrains. A bag made from strong, water-resistant materials will protect the contents and last longer under challenging conditions.

Accessibility is vital during touring because stops are often brief, and riders need to grab items quickly. A well-designed bag allows easy access to frequently used items without having to unpack everything.

Stability and fit are necessary to ensure that the saddle bag remains securely attached to the bike throughout the journey. A bag that shifts while riding can be distracting and may even pose a safety risk.

The attachment system should be straightforward, allowing for quick mounting and removal of the bag. This feature is particularly important for touring cyclists who may need to dismount and secure their gear frequently.

Pockets and organization features within the bag enhance usability by allowing cyclists to categorize their gear. This organization helps in quickly locating tools, snacks, or other essential items while on the move.

Reflective elements on the saddle bag improve visibility during nighttime rides or in low-light conditions, contributing to the safety of the cyclist. This feature is especially important for those touring on busy roads.

Lastly, the weight of the saddle bag itself should be minimal to avoid adding unnecessary bulk to the bike. A lightweight design helps maintain optimal handling and performance, which is crucial for long-distance touring.

How Important Is Capacity When Choosing a Touring Saddle Bag?

Compartments: Having multiple compartments can help organize your items efficiently, making it easier to access necessities while on the road. This organization is crucial during touring when quick access to items like tools or snacks can enhance the riding experience.

Weight Distribution: The design and capacity affect how weight is distributed on the bike, influencing handling and rider comfort during long rides. A well-designed saddle bag should balance the load so that it does not negatively impact the bike’s stability or the rider’s control.

Material Durability: The capacity must be matched with durable materials to ensure that the bag can hold its contents securely without tearing or failing. High-quality materials can withstand the rigors of touring, including varying weather conditions and rough terrains.

Expandable Features: Some saddle bags come with expandable options, allowing you to increase capacity when needed while keeping a compact profile for easy handling. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for touring, where gear needs can vary from day to day.

Which Materials Offer Optimal Durability and Weather Resistance for Touring?

The best saddle bags for touring prioritize durability and weather resistance, ensuring that your gear stays protected during long rides.

  • Cordura Nylon: This synthetic fabric is known for its exceptional resistance to abrasion and tearing. It is often treated with water-repellent coatings, making it a popular choice for touring saddle bags that need to withstand harsh weather conditions.
  • Polyester: Lightweight and durable, polyester is often used in saddle bags for its affordability and resistance to fading. High-denier polyester versions are particularly effective at repelling water and resisting wear, making them suitable for longer tours.
  • Canvas: A traditional material, canvas offers a rugged look and strong durability. When treated with waterproofing agents, canvas saddle bags can provide excellent weather resistance while maintaining breathability, which is useful for keeping contents dry in humid conditions.
  • Leather: Known for its classic aesthetic, leather can offer great durability and weather resistance when properly treated with oils or waxes. While heavier than synthetic materials, high-quality leather saddle bags can withstand years of use and develop a unique character over time.
  • Tarpaulin: This heavy-duty, waterproof material is designed to endure extreme conditions, making it an excellent choice for touring bags that need to keep gear completely dry. Tarpaulin bags are also resistant to UV rays and punctures, ensuring longevity even on the toughest rides.

What Are the Top Options for Saddle Bags for Touring Riders?

The best saddle bags for touring riders combine durability, capacity, and ease of access to enhance long-distance riding experiences.

  • Kriega US-30 Drypack: This bag is designed for waterproof performance and features a roll-top closure to keep your gear dry. Its modular design allows it to be combined with other Kriega bags, offering versatility for different touring needs.
  • Nelson-Rigg SE-3050: Known for its spacious interior and weather-resistant materials, this bag comes with a waterproof rain cover and reflective piping for added safety. Its easy-to-use mounting system ensures secure attachment to various bike models.
  • Wolfman Expedition Saddle Bags: Made from tough, durable materials, these bags are designed to handle rough conditions and have a waterproof liner. They also feature a unique mounting system that keeps them stable and secure while riding.
  • SW-MOTECH Blaze Saddle Bags: These bags are semi-rigid, making them easy to load and unload while still providing a streamlined profile. They come with an adjustable mounting system and can be quickly removed when not in use, offering flexibility for touring riders.
  • Viking Bags Ghost Saddlebags: With a sleek look and ample storage space, these bags are made from high-quality leather and feature quick-release buckles for easy access. They are also designed to fit a wide range of motorcycles, making them a versatile choice for touring enthusiasts.

Which Saddle Bags Are Most Recommended for Long-Distance Touring?

The best saddle bags for long-distance touring are those that offer ample storage, durability, and ease of use.

  • Wolfman Rainier Saddle Bags: Known for their rugged construction and waterproof capabilities, these bags are designed to keep your gear dry during extended trips. They feature a roll-top closure that provides additional waterproofing and are easy to attach to most bike models.
  • Givi EA112 Easy-T Range Saddle Bags: These bags come with a versatile mounting system and are made from durable materials that resist wear and tear. Their spacious design allows for a significant amount of cargo, while reflective elements enhance visibility during night rides.
  • Kriega OS-32 Adventure Saddle Bags: The Kriega OS-32 bags are highly durable and versatile, featuring a modular design that allows for easy expansion. They are made from waterproof materials and include a unique mounting system that keeps the bags secure even on rough terrains.
  • SW-Motech Legend Gear LC1 Saddle Bag: This bag combines vintage aesthetics with modern functionality, featuring a waterproof inner liner and durable waxed canvas construction. It includes a quick-release mounting system that facilitates easy installation and removal, making it suitable for touring trips.
  • Nelson-Rigg RG-1040 Waterproof Saddle Bags: These bags are crafted from heavy-duty, waterproof material and feature a unique design that minimizes wind resistance. With their generous capacity and reflective strips for safety, they are ideal for long-distance touring in various weather conditions.

What Are the Best Saddle Bags Based on User Reviews and Ratings for Comfort and Fit?

The best saddle bags for touring are often praised for their comfort, fit, and user-friendly features based on extensive reviews and ratings.

  • Ortlieb Bike Packer Plus: Known for its waterproof capabilities, this bag features a roll-top closure that ensures your belongings stay dry even in heavy rain. Its durable construction and reflective elements enhance visibility, making it ideal for long-distance touring.
  • Revelate Designs Viscacha: This bag is designed for versatility, combining a seat bag with a dry bag, which is perfect for touring. Its unique attachment system allows for a secure fit on various bike frames while maintaining a sleek profile that minimizes wind resistance.
  • Topeak BackLoader: This innovative saddle bag features a unique compression system that optimizes packing space and keeps your load stable while riding. Its waterproof fabric keeps contents safe from moisture, and the quick-release mounting system allows for easy installation and removal.
  • Blackburn Outpost Elite: A highly rated option for its spacious design, this bag can hold a significant amount of gear while maintaining comfort on long rides. The adjustable straps and additional pockets provide excellent organization and accessibility for touring cyclists.
  • Salsa EXP Series Seat Pack: This bag is designed specifically for bikepacking and touring, featuring a roll-top closure for waterproofing and an aerodynamic shape that reduces drag. Its durable materials and additional attachment points make it a favorite for those looking to carry extra gear on multi-day adventures.

How Can You Effectively Pack and Organize a Saddle Bag for Touring?

Effectively packing and organizing a saddle bag for touring involves careful selection of items and strategic placement for easy access and balance.

  • Waterproof Liner: A waterproof liner is essential for protecting your belongings from rain and moisture. It ensures that your gear remains dry, which is crucial for electronics and clothing, especially during long tours where weather can be unpredictable.
  • Compression Straps: Compression straps help to secure your items tightly within the saddle bag. This reduces movement while riding, preventing items from shifting, which can affect balance and make riding uncomfortable.
  • First Aid Kit: Having a first aid kit packed in your saddle bag is vital for any touring adventure. It should include band-aids, antiseptic wipes, pain relievers, and any personal medications to address minor injuries or ailments that may occur on the road.
  • Multi-Tool: A multi-tool is an invaluable item for any cyclist. It allows for quick repairs and adjustments on the go, ensuring you can fix a flat tire or tighten loose components without needing to carry a full toolbox.
  • Spare Tube and Pump: Carrying a spare tube and a portable pump is essential for dealing with flat tires. Being prepared allows you to quickly get back on the road without relying on external help, enhancing your independence during the tour.
  • Clothing Layering: Packing clothes in layers is key to adapting to changing weather conditions. Lightweight, moisture-wicking fabrics that can be easily rolled or packed will save space and provide comfort during varying temperatures.
  • Snack Packs: Having snacks readily available in your saddle bag can help maintain your energy levels while touring. Power bars, nuts, or dried fruit are compact and provide quick fuel, making them ideal for long stretches between meals.
  • Navigation Tools: Including navigation tools such as a map, GPS device, or smartphone with offline maps can prevent getting lost. This ensures you stay on track and make the most of your touring experience without unnecessary detours.
  • Lightweight Camping Gear: If your tour includes overnight stays, packing lightweight camping gear is essential. A compact sleeping bag, tent, or hammock can be organized efficiently in the saddle bag, allowing you to rest comfortably at the end of the day.

What Maintenance Tips Should You Follow to Extend the Life of Your Saddle Bag?

To extend the life of your saddle bag, several maintenance tips should be followed.

  • Regular Cleaning: It’s essential to clean your saddle bag regularly to remove dirt and debris that can cause wear over time. Use a soft cloth and a mild soap solution, ensuring you rinse it thoroughly and allow it to dry completely to prevent mold or mildew.
  • Inspect for Damage: Frequently inspect your saddle bag for any signs of wear, such as frayed stitching, tears, or broken zippers. Early detection allows for timely repairs, which can prevent further damage and extend the life of the bag.
  • Proper Storage: When not in use, store your saddle bag in a cool, dry place, ideally in a protective cover. Avoid storing it in direct sunlight or damp areas, as these conditions can degrade materials over time.
  • Waterproofing Treatments: If your saddle bag is not already waterproof, consider applying a waterproofing treatment to protect it from rain and moisture. This will help preserve the integrity of the materials and prevent water damage.
  • Avoid Overloading: Adhere to the weight limits specified by the manufacturer and avoid overloading your saddle bag. Excessive weight can strain the seams and zippers, leading to premature failure.
  • Routine Maintenance: Make it a habit to perform routine maintenance, such as tightening buckles, checking straps, and lubricating zippers to ensure smooth operation. This proactive approach can prevent minor issues from escalating into significant problems.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment